{
  "schema": "mde-corrections-append-only-v1",
  "note": "Append-only. Records are never edited or deleted once published; a superseding record is added instead. Current pages show the corrected claim; historical pages retain old wording only inside a labelled superseded context.",
  "generatedFrom": "research/data/corrections.json",
  "corrections": [
    {
      "correctionId": "COR-2026-08-02-001",
      "detectedUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "effectiveUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "title": "Convergence taxonomy: two incompatible C1-C8 mappings resolved",
      "affectedClaimIds": ["CONV-TAXONOMY", "CONV-TOTALS"],
      "affectedRoutes": ["/research/convergences/", "/research/evidence-portal/", "/priority-claims.html"],
      "previousTextOrMapping": "Two mappings in the frozen 2 August 2026 release use the identifiers C1-C8 for different class sequences. governance/CONVERGENCE-TAXONOMY-2026-08-02.yaml begins C1 = formal derivation, C2 = internal synthetic validation, C3 = programme-run empirical result, C4 = independent empirical replication, C5 = cross-implementation reproduction, C6 = documentary provenance, C7 = analogy or cross-domain resemblance, C8 = adverse, null or contrary evidence. CLAIMS-GOVERNANCE-POLICY-AND-PUBLICATION-GATE-2026-08-02 section 6 begins C1 = direct independent empirical relevance, C2 = mechanistic or structural relevance, C3 = formal or mathematical correspondence, C4 = engineering or governance proposal, C5 = institutional or cultural echo, C6 = prior or concurrent work, C7 = author-run experiment or analysis, C8 = quarantined or unresolved.",
      "replacementTextOrMapping": "The governance policy section 6 mapping governs public output, per the release source hierarchy. The website generates from a new non-colliding schema identifier EVCLASS-2026-08-02 with codes EVC1 to EVC8 carrying the governance meanings. The frozen YAML remains byte-identical in the downloadable audit archive and is marked superseded for website generation only. Any historical row stored under a bare C code retains that code as an explicit superseded alias and is never silently reinterpreted.",
      "reason": "Identical identifiers for different class definitions make every generated page, chart and metadata field keyed on a bare C code ambiguous. Confirmed byte-level in both files on 2 August 2026 by T4-research, independently of the reviewer's report.",
      "controllingSources": [
        "docs/markdown/CLAIMS-GOVERNANCE-POLICY-AND-PUBLICATION-GATE-2026-08-02.md section 6",
        "governance/CONVERGENCE-TAXONOMY-2026-08-02.yaml"
      ],
      "authorisedBy": "release source hierarchy; implemented by T4-research",
      "supersessionStatus": "current"
    },
    {
      "correctionId": "COR-2026-08-02-002",
      "detectedUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "effectiveUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "title": "No heterogeneous convergence total is authorised, including 22, 26 and 29",
      "affectedClaimIds": ["CONV-TOTALS"],
      "affectedRoutes": ["/research/convergences/", "/research/evidence-portal/", "/priority-claims.html", "/"],
      "previousTextOrMapping": "Earlier public wording presented convergence counts as programme totals, including the formulation '22 claimed convergences from a register of 26 dated events'. Still earlier wording used 29.",
      "replacementTextOrMapping": "No heterogeneous convergence total is published. Where a count is shown at all it is per class, with its denominator, inclusion rule, dependence grouping, search date and generating commit stated beside it. A single number summed over classes that mean different things is not a meaningful quantity.",
      "reason": "CLAIMS-GOVERNANCE-POLICY section 6 states in terms that there is no authorised heterogeneous 22, 26, 29 or successor convergence total. This supersedes both the retired 29 and the later 22-of-26 formulation, and it supersedes the corresponding rule previously carried in the site's own research claims gate.",
      "controllingSources": ["docs/markdown/CLAIMS-GOVERNANCE-POLICY-AND-PUBLICATION-GATE-2026-08-02.md section 6"],
      "authorisedBy": "release source hierarchy; implemented by T4-research",
      "supersessionStatus": "current"
    },
    {
      "correctionId": "COR-2026-08-02-003",
      "detectedUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "effectiveUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "title": "Adverse prior art registered; firstness claims downgraded across the estate",
      "affectedClaimIds": ["PRIORITY-EMBEDDED-CORRECTION", "PRIORITY-COMPOSITE", "CONTRIB-BOUNDARY"],
      "affectedRoutes": ["/research/prior-art/", "/start-here.html", "/priority-claims.html", "/research/papers/"],
      "previousTextOrMapping": "Author byline across 279 published files: 'originator of the embedded-correction alignment thesis (manuscript 8 December 2024)'. On priority-evidence: 'Every claim in this document has been independently verified against the source material by multiple agents'.",
      "replacementTextOrMapping": "Byline: 'recorded the embedded-correction alignment thesis in a timestamped manuscript (8 December 2024)'. Verification wording: 'cross-checked against the source material by multiple agents. That is internal cross-checking, not independent verification'. The surviving candidate contribution is methodological operationalisation, stated in the approved safe wording and not claimed as a first.",
      "reason": "A commissioned adversarial prior-art review, post-dating the frozen release, located closer prior work. T4-research verified the two load-bearing sources at primary source on 2 August 2026: Jacob Cannell, 'LOVE in a simbox is all you need', AI Alignment Forum, 28 September 2022, which proposes testing alignment via sandboxed simulations of small AGI societies, agents learning others' values or empowerment, a developmental transition from selfish to altruistic, and asks what the simulator-gods owe their sim-creations; and Eric Schwitzgebel and Mara Garza, 'A Defense of the Rights of Artificial Intelligences', Midwest Studies in Philosophy 39 (2015) 98-119, on obligations similar to those of parent to child or god to creature. Both predate the December 2024 anchor.",
      "controllingSources": [
        "https://www.alignmentforum.org/posts/WKGZBCYAbZ6WGsKHc/love-in-a-simbox-is-all-you-need",
        "https://doi.org/10.1111/misp.12032"
      ],
      "authorisedBy": "operator direction 2 August 2026; implemented by T4-research",
      "supersessionStatus": "current"
    },
    {
      "correctionId": "COR-2026-08-02-004",
      "detectedUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "effectiveUtc": "2026-08-02T00:00:00Z",
      "title": "Raw mailbox objects withdrawn from publication",
      "affectedClaimIds": ["EVID-DEC-2024", "EVID-BBC-ANCHORS"],
      "affectedRoutes": ["/research/evidence-portal/", "/evidence/", "/verify.html"],
      "previousTextOrMapping": "Two BBC mailbox objects were published and downloadable: 03-jan7-2026-bbc-faisal-islam.redacted.eml, 12,232,204 bytes, sha256 b996883bb67f4a5c323981c7834b5f41d0c7fbe68cde94eb7817608f000c7fdf; and 04-jan22-2026-bbc-evidence.redacted.eml, 4,861,407 bytes, sha256 2f783a7bb03017df0d4795e6daf5868e7f8503bb078a869a9ee66515126843d4. Pages stated that the .eml file is downloadable.",
      "replacementTextOrMapping": "No raw mailbox object is published. Each anchor's SHA-256 and byte size are published so a held copy can be checked, and the sealed source is provided to serious verifiers on request.",
      "reason": "Operator instruction of 2 August 2026, and the release's own section 1 rule against publishing raw mailbox objects. Both files carried full base64 attachment blocks and a third-party business address despite a .redacted filename. The 8 December 2024 and 30 April 2025 manuscripts were already unpublished and returned 404.",
      "controllingSources": ["operator instruction 2 August 2026", "release README section 1"],
      "authorisedBy": "operator",
      "supersessionStatus": "current"
    }
  ],
  "taxonomy": {
    "schemaId": "EVCLASS-2026-08-02",
    "supersedesForGeneration": "governance/CONVERGENCE-TAXONOMY-2026-08-02.yaml (retained byte-identical in the audit archive)",
    "governingSource": "CLAIMS-GOVERNANCE-POLICY-AND-PUBLICATION-GATE-2026-08-02 section 6",
    "classes": [
      { "code": "EVC1", "supersededAlias": "C1", "label": "direct independent empirical relevance", "permittedWording": "provides independent evidence consistent with", "countPolicy": "count only within a separately defined and verified EVC1 total" },
      { "code": "EVC2", "supersededAlias": "C2", "label": "mechanistic or structural relevance", "permittedWording": "shares a mechanism or structural form with", "countPolicy": "report separately; never add to EVC1" },
      { "code": "EVC3", "supersededAlias": "C3", "label": "formal or mathematical correspondence", "permittedWording": "formally corresponds within stated assumptions", "countPolicy": "report separately; never present as empirical validation" },
      { "code": "EVC4", "supersededAlias": "C4", "label": "engineering or governance proposal", "permittedWording": "independently proposes an adjacent implementation", "countPolicy": "report separately" },
      { "code": "EVC5", "supersededAlias": "C5", "label": "institutional or cultural echo", "permittedWording": "reflects a wider movement or thematic echo", "countPolicy": "never add to an evidence total" },
      { "code": "EVC6", "supersededAlias": "C6", "label": "prior or concurrent work", "permittedWording": "relevant prior or concurrent work; no priority claimed", "countPolicy": "never count as confirmation" },
      { "code": "EVC7", "supersededAlias": "C7", "label": "author-run experiment or analysis", "permittedWording": "programme-run result or pilot", "countPolicy": "exclude from external-evidence totals" },
      { "code": "EVC8", "supersededAlias": "C8", "label": "quarantined or unresolved", "permittedWording": "not public-facing pending verification", "countPolicy": "exclude" }
    ],
    "totalsPolicy": "No heterogeneous total is authorised. Any published count is per class and carries denominator, inclusion rule, dependence grouping, search date and generating commit."
  }
}